Most plumbers I talk to are not worried about marketing, until the phone gets weirdly quiet. You are still doing good work, you are still answering calls, but somehow fewer “new” customers are finding you. A big reason is that homeowners are changing how they search. They are asking ChatGPT, Google’s AI, and other tools who to call, then they pick from a short list. Plumber marketing strategies in the age of AI are about one thing: making it easy for both humans and machines to trust you.
How homeowners actually find a plumber now (and why it matters)
A homeowner with a leaking water heater does not want a marketing journey. They want a fast answer they can trust.
More and more, that looks like:
- They ask Google and see an AI summary at the top.
- They ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, or another assistant, “Who is a good plumber near me?”
- They text a neighbor, then still check reviews before calling.
- They click one business, skim photos, scan reviews, and hit “Call.”
AI tools pull from a mix of sources, like business listings, review sites, your website, local news, and general “talk” about your business online. If your info is inconsistent, your services are unclear, or your reviews are thin, you might still rank “fine” in old-school search, but you get skipped in AI recommendations.
If you want a deeper breakdown of how the main AI platforms are different, this is worth knowing: ChatGPT vs AI Overviews vs Grok vs Perplexity - What.
Is AI Recommending Your Business?
See how you stack up against your competitors and let Pantora get you to the top.
Get your basics right, because AI punishes confusion
This part is not exciting, but it is the foundation. AI does not “guess” kindly. If your business details look messy across the web, you create doubt, and doubt kills calls.
Here’s what I would tighten up first:
1. Make your business name, address, and phone consistent everywhere.
Your Google Business Profile, website header and footer, Yelp, Facebook, Angi, BBB, local chamber listings, and any directory you are on should match exactly. Same formatting, same suite number, same phone number.
2. Pick a clear service area and stick to it.
If you truly serve the whole metro, say that, but be specific where you can. AI responses often include “near X neighborhood” language, and you want those places to match what you actually cover.
3. Be specific about services, not just “plumbing.”
On your site and listings, spell out your money-makers in plain language:
- Water heater repair and replacement (tank and tankless)
- Drain cleaning and hydro jetting
- Sewer line camera inspection
- Toilet installation and repair
- Sump pump replacement
- Gas line work (only if you actually do it)
- Emergency plumbing
A lot of plumbing websites stay vague because the owner assumes “people know what we do.” AI does not assume. It looks for explicit proof.
4. Show real photos that match real jobs.
Stock images are a trust killer. Upload photos of your truck, your team, clean installs, and before-and-after shots. Homeowners want to see that you are a real local company, not a lead-gen middleman.
Reviews are not just for Google anymore, they are training data for trust
If you only change one thing this month, make it your review system. Reviews are one of the strongest signals that you are legit, responsive, and good at what you do, and those signals get reused in AI answers.
The mistake most plumbers make is treating reviews like a “nice to have.” You need a simple, repeatable process.
What to ask for in reviews (so they help you win better jobs)
Homeowners write better reviews when you give them a little direction. After the job, send a short text like:
“Hey [Name], glad we got that [water heater / main line / clogged kitchen drain] handled. If you have a minute, would you leave a quick review? It helps a ton. Here’s the link.”
And if you want better quality reviews, add one more line:
“If you mention what we fixed and the area you’re in, it helps neighbors find us.”
That prompts reviews that say things like “replaced a 50-gallon water heater in [town]” or “cleared a main sewer line backup,” which is exactly the kind of detail AI tools love.
How many reviews do you need?
There is no magic number, but consistency matters. A plumbing company with a steady stream of recent reviews usually looks safer than one with a big pile of old reviews and nothing recent. Aim for a small weekly target you can hit without fail.
How to handle a bad review without making it worse
Do not argue. Do not write a novel. Keep it calm:
- Thank them for the feedback.
- State the intent to make it right.
- Move it offline with a phone number or request to contact you.
AI systems read tone. Future customers read tone. Your response is often more important than the complaint.
If you want the plumber-specific breakdown of why this matters so much in AI results, go here: Why Reviews Matter More for AI Than Traditional SEO for Plumbers.
Build “answerable” website pages that match what people ask AI
Most plumbing websites are built like brochures. In the age of AI, your site also needs to function like a clear set of answers.
Think about the questions people actually ask:
- “How much does a water heater replacement cost?”
- “Do I need a plumber for low water pressure?”
- “Is a slow drain a main line problem?”
- “Do you install tankless water heaters?”
- “Can you come today?”
You do not need to publish pricing that boxes you in, but you should give ranges, factors, and next steps. AI tools prefer sources that explain things clearly and safely.
Pages that tend to perform well for plumbing companies:
- A dedicated page for each core service (not one “Services” page)
- A page for emergency plumbing that explains what counts as an emergency
- A “Service Areas” page that lists towns and neighborhoods you actually serve
- A “Water Heater Replacement” page that covers tank vs tankless, permits (if relevant), disposal, and what the job includes
- A “Sewer Line Repair” page that explains symptoms, camera inspection, and options (spot repair vs replacement)
Make it easy to prove you are local and real Add the basics that homeowners look for fast:
- License and insurance info (if applicable in your state)
- Warranty or workmanship guarantee
- A real contact page with your address or service area
- A short “About” section that says who you are and how you work
Also, do not hide your phone number behind a form. Plumbing is a “call now” category.
Practical plumber marketing strategies you can implement this week
You do not need a big rebrand or a new logo to win in AI-driven search. You need a tight presence and a simple system.
Here’s a realistic weekly plan:
-
Pick one service to feature.
This week, choose something like water heater replacement or drain cleaning. -
Add 3 job photos and one short write-up to your site or Google Business Profile.
Just the facts. “Replaced failed expansion tank and installed new PRV, tested pressure, cleaned up.” -
Ask for 5 reviews, on purpose.
Text customers right after you finish, when the relief is highest. -
Check your top listings for consistency.
Google Business Profile, Yelp, Facebook, Angi. Make sure your phone and service area match. -
Write one FAQ that matches a real question you hear.
Example: “Why does my water heater make popping noises?” Answer it in 200 to 400 words.
If you also want ideas for getting leads from AI-driven channels beyond just rankings, this article gives a good roadmap: AI-Driven Lead Generation Strategies for Home Service Businesses.
How to track whether you are showing up in AI recommendations
This is the part that frustrates people. With Google, you can at least see rankings and clicks. With AI, your business can be mentioned one day and missing the next, and you might never know.
What you want to track:
- Are you being recommended for “plumber near me” style prompts in your service area?
- What reasons does AI give when it mentions you (reviews, responsiveness, specialties)?
- Which competitors show up instead of you, and what do they have that you do not?
- Are your services described correctly, or is AI making wrong assumptions?
If you want to see whether these changes are actually working, Pantora tracks how your business shows up across AI platforms and gives you a clear to-do list to improve your chances of being recommended.
Common reasons plumbers do not show up in AI results (and what to fix)
If you feel like you are doing “everything” and still not getting recommended, it is usually one of these issues:
Your online info is scattered.
Old phone numbers, outdated addresses, duplicate listings, or mismatched business names create uncertainty.
Your reviews are too thin, too old, or too generic.
“Great service” is nice, but it does not tell AI what you are great at. You want reviews that mention the actual work, like “tankless install,” “main line clog,” or “sump pump replacement.”
Your website does not clearly say what you do and where you do it.
If your homepage just says “quality plumbing services” and “call today,” you are not giving AI enough to work with.
You look like a lead broker.
No photos, no address or service area clarity, no team info, and a form-only contact setup can make you look like a middleman.
You are missing the “trust extras.”
Licensing, insurance, warranties, and clear policies reduce hesitation. That hesitation shows up in both human behavior and AI selections.
When you fix these, the payoff is not just “AI visibility.” You usually get more calls from regular search too, because you look more trustworthy everywhere.
Conclusion
AI is not replacing word-of-mouth, it is becoming word-of-mouth at scale. The plumbers who win are the ones who make their business easy to understand and easy to trust, with consistent listings, steady reviews, and clear service pages. Pick two improvements you can finish this week, then keep the cadence. The goal is simple: when a homeowner asks an AI who to call, your name shows up with the right reasons attached.